Appliance Tip of the Day: Buying a Replacement or Add-on Icemaker
by Samurai Appliance Repair Man
Looking to replace your dearly departed icemaker? Sick of filling ice cube trays and you’re finally going to install an icemaker kit in your fridge? This handy table will help you figger out which kit you need. If you’re seeking wisdom on troubleshooting and repair or installing a water supply line for your icemaker, just click the preceding links. Otherwise, let the table below be your guiding light.
| Refrigerator | Replacement or Add-On [1] |
Icemaker Kit to Buy |
| Whirlpool and Kenmore with Flat-Style Plug [2] | Add-On | Whirlpool Add-on Icemaker Kit w/ Flat Plug |
| Whirlpool and Kenmore with Round-Style Plug [2] | Add-On | Whirlpool Add-on Icemaker Kit w/ Round Plug |
| Whirlpool and Kenmore | Replacement | Whirlpool Replacement Icemaker [3] |
| Whirlpool and Roper made from 1993 to present. | Add-On | Whirlpool Icemaker Kit w/ Flat Plug |
| Maytag, Magic Chef, Admiral and Jenn-Air. 1989 to current. | Add-On | Maytag Add-On Icemaker Kit |
| GE and Hotpoint. 1987 to present. | Add-On | GE Add-On Icemaker Kit |
| Frigidaire, Westinghouse, Kelvinator, Tappan, Kenmore (253 series), and Gibson brands (IK4, IK7, IK8). | Add-On | Frigidaire Add-On Icemaker Kit |
| Amana with Round-Style Plug [2] | Add-On | Amana Add-On Icemaker Kit |
| Amana with 4-Pin Male Receptacle [2] | Add-On | Amana Add-On Icemaker Kit |
| All Brands | Add-On | Copper Icemaker Water Installation Kit [4] |
| Whirlpool and Kenmore with Flex Tray Icemaker | Replacement | Icemaker Defrost Timer [5] |
Notes:
[1] Replacement means you’re replacing an existing icemaker in a fridge that already had one. Add-On means you’re installing an icemaker kit in a fridge that never had one. Add-on kits come with the water valve and ice bin, replacement kits do not. You can use an add-on kit for a replacement but you can’t use a replacement kit for an add-on.
[2] The style of plug refers to the type of icemaker electrical receptacle that you can see on back wall inside your freezer.
[3] Kit comes with both a flat and round receptacle plug.
[4] This is the type of water installation kit recommended by manufacturers. Uses only genuine copper tubing with a drill-type saddle tap valve. For more information, see this page.
[5] The defrost timer is built into the flex tray icemaker. If you just want to get rid of the flex tray icemaker in your fridge, you’ll need to install this replacement defrost timer kit or your fridge won’t run. You’ll have a hard time finding a replacement flex tray icemaker because they suck so bad. If yours is busted and you can’t fix it, you’re better off without it.

Ice Maker Repair FAQs
- Troubleshooting Flowchart for the Whirlpool-built Modular Icemaker
- Manually Starting the Harvest Cycle in the Whirlpool-Built Modular Icemaker
- Repair Guide for the Whirlpool-built Stand-Alone Ice Machine
- Buying a Replacement or Add-on Ice Maker
- Ice Maker Ice Mold Flaking Off Crud into the Ice
- Icemaker Repair FAQ
- Icemaker Fill Tube Freezing
- Broken Ice Dispenser on a GE Refrigerator
- How to Fix a Frozen Ice Bin Augur in a GE Refrigerator
- How to Diagnose the Emitter and Receiver Boards in the Optical-Sensing Icemakers
- Icemakers in Frigidaire Refrigerators Stop Making Ice
- Broken Icemaker? Buy a New Refrigerator!
- Appliance Repair Revelation: Installing an Icemaker Water Supply Line
- Appliance Repair Revelation: Icemaker FAQ
- Attention Maytag and Amana Refrigerator Owners
- Mailbag: Icemaker Water Supply Hookup
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Icemaker Water Filters
- Mailbag: Ice Maker that Melts Ice
- Mailbag: Installing a Water Supply Line for a Refrigerator
- Mailbag: Stinky Ice!
- Appliance Tip of the Day: No Ice in Your Whirlpool or KitchenAid Side-by-Side Fridge with In-Door Ice
- Appliance Tip of the Day: The New GE IM6 Icemaker
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Icemaker Water Filters
Refrigerator Repair FAQs
- Maytag Ice2O French Door Refrigerator/Freezer Model MFI2568AEW HV Control Board Repair Instruction Guide
- What Brand of Kitchen and Laundry Appliances Would the Samurai Buy?
- Activating Self Diagnostic Mode in a GE Arctica Refrigerator
- Service Update: Non-serviceable Frigidaire Refrigerators
- Viking Range Corporation Recalls Built-In Refrigerators Due to Injury Hazard; Doors Can Detach
- How to Replace the Adaptive Defrost Control (ADC) Board in a Maytag Refrigerator
- Frigidaire Side-by-Side Refrigerator PHS69EHSS3 Wiring Diagram and Parts Manual
- The Permanent Cure for Repeatedly Freezing Condensate Drains in Whirlpool-Roper-Kitchenaid Top-Mount Refrigerators
- All Samsung Refrigerators have a Lurking Defrost Nightmare Problem: An Uncool Haiku
- Entering Diagnostic Mode in a GE Monogram Refrigerator Model ZISS480DRASS
- How to Manually Initiate the Defrost Cycle in a GE Arctica Side-by-Side Refrigerator
- Service Manual for the LG LRSC26930 Side-by-Side Refrigerator
- Service Manual: Maytag GC2225...
- What to Check When Your Refrig...
- Whirlpool / Kenmore Refrigerat...
- Maytag / Jenn-Air Refrigerator Not Cooling Properly in the Refrigerator Section
- The Noise You DON'T Wanna Hear from Your Refrigerator
- FAQs for Replacing the Motherboard in a GE Refrigerator
- Maytag recalls 1.6 Million Refrigerators
- How to Repair a Refrigerator
- No Water from the Dispenser on a GE Refrigerator
- The Permanent Cure for Repeated Frost-Up Problems in a Maytag Side-By-Side Refrigerator
- How to Test the Defrost System in a GE Arctica or Profile Refrigerator
- GE or Hotpoint Refrigerator Makes Lots of Weird Noises
- Maytag ICELAND Refrigerator Temperature Settings Cannot be Changed
- Eyeball Test for a Bad Defrost Thermostat
- GE Arctica Refrigerator Gets Really Hot During Defrost
- GE Profile Arctica: No Water from the Door Water Dispenser
- How to Repair a Leaking Evaporator in Your Refrigerator
- Amana Refrigerator, Less Than Four Years Old, DOA and Amana Won't Honor the Warranty
- Ice Maker Ice Mold Flaking Off Crud into the Ice
- Refrigerator Blowing Warm Air in the Icebox
- Desperately Seeking Chill
- Whirlpool Refrigerator Water Dispenser With a Case of the Drips
- Refrigerator Compressor Hums but Won't Start
- GE Side by Side Refrigerator Freezing the Beer
- Refrigerator Repair FAQ
- GE Profile Refrigerator Leaking from the Water Dispenser
- The Complete DIY Refrigerator Repair Reference
- Broken Ice Dispenser on a GE Refrigerator
- Does Your Refrigerator have a Freon Leak?
- The Portable Refrigerator Repair Manual
- How to Replace the Evaporator Fan in a Maytag Refrigerator
- Haiku for Installing a New Compressor in a Refrigerator: A Song of Degrees
- Refrigerator Lost Its Cool
- How to Fix a Frozen Ice Bin Augur in a GE Refrigerator
- Motherboard Recall on GE Refrigerators
- How to Manually Start the Defrost Cycle in Frigidaire Refrigerators
- Travails and Ultimate Triumph in a Maytag Refrigerator Repair
- Water Dispenser in a Maytag Refrigerator Floods the Kitchen
- How to Diagnose the Emitter and Receiver Boards in the Optical-Sensing Icemakers
- Checking the Thermistor in GE Refrigerators
- Amana Side by Side Refrigerator Intermittently Warms Up
- Fear and Loathing in a Sub-Zero Refrigerator Sealed System Repair
- How to Replace the Adaptive Defrost Control (ADC) Board in your Maytag or Jenn-Air SxS Refrigerator
- How to Replace the Evaporator Fan and Motherboard in a GE Arctica Refrigerator
- Defrosting Problem on GE SxS Refrigerators with the Motherboard in Back
- Whirlpool / Kenmore Refrigerator with Chronic Water Leaking Problem Inside the Beer Compartment
- Temperature Regulation Problems in a Sub-Zero 642 (600-series) Refrigerator
- GE Refrigerator Class Action Lawsuit Update
- GE Arctica Refrigerator Troubleshooting Tech Sheet
- Error Codes for the Sub-Zero 600 Series Refrigerators
- Appliantology Newsletter, Summer 2006 Issue is Now Out!
- Sub-Zero 561 Refrigerator Icing On Back Wall
- The Disposable Chest Freezer Made by Haier and Sold by Sears as the "Kenmore Access Plus"
- Refrigerator Noises
- Defrost Drain Cup Keeps Freezing Over in Older Model Whirlpool-built Refrigerators
- Kenmore SxS Refrigerator, Beer Compartment Warm... Mayday! Mayday!
- GE Refrigerator Ice Dispenser Door Not Opening
- GE Profile Refrigerator (Includes the Arctica and Eterna Models) Freezing Food in the Beer Compartment
- GE Arctica Refrigerator: Broken Air Damper and Everything's Freezing in the Beer Compartment!
- Excessive Compressor Failures in Frigidaire / Kenmore Refrigerators
- Appliance Repair Radio Update
- Frigidaire Side by Side Refrigerators: Air Damper Control Problem, Stuff Freezing in the Beer Compartment!
- Icemakers in Frigidaire Refrigerators Stop Making Ice
- Frigidaire ice dispenser out of control
- Refrigerator Warming Up and Makes an Occasional Clicking Noise
- Has Your Refrigerator or Freezer Been Recalled?
- The Story of "O!" (that being our painful exclamation as we get screwed again and again by Big Gubmint and Big Corporations)
- What to Check When Your Refrigerator or Freezer is Warming Up; refrigerator warm; refrigerator repair
- GE Fridge - Cold Freezer with warm refrigerator - The Kitchen - Appliance Repair Hut - The Samurai Appliance Repair Forums
- GE Refrigerator Defrost System Problems; refrigerator repair
- Clearing a Frozen Icemaker Fill Tube
- Field Notes: Maytag Side-by-Side Refrigerator Warming Up
- Technique of the Master: Wiring in a New Defrost Thermostat
- Whirlpool Refrigerator Getting Warm
- Kenmore Refrigerator - bottom of door collapsed?
- Mailbag: Initiating the Harvest Cycle on a Modular Icemaker
- Jenn Air Fridge Warm, Adaptive Defrost Control Board
- Appliance Repair Revelation: Installing an Icemaker Water Supply Line
- Online Refrigerator Repair Manual
- Appliance Repair Revelation: Zen and the Art of Refrigerator Door Gasket Replacement
- Appliance Repair Revelation: The Cold Facts About Refrigerator Controls
- Mailbag: Cold Air Port Periodically Freezes Up and Blocks Cold Air
- Mailbag: Diagnosing Refrigerator Defrosting Problems
- Mailbag: Whirlpool Old-Style Icemaker Doesn't Make Much Ice
- Attention Maytag and Amana Refrigerator Owners
- Mailbag: Slow Flow from a Refrigerator Water Dispenser
- Mailbag: Amana Refrigerator Freezing Everything
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Icemaker Water Filters
- Fridge Talk
- Mailbag: Water Leaking from a Refrigerator
- Service Manual for GE Arctica and Profile Refrigerators
- Mailbag: Clearing a Plugged Condensate Drain Tube in a Refrigerator
- Mailbag: Ice Maker that Melts Ice
- Mailbag: Poor Cooling and Water Accumulating Inside a Refrigerator
- Mailbag: Installing a Water Supply Line for a Refrigerator
- Samurai on the Job: Amana Model SXDE25JP SxS Refrigerator
- Mailbag: Fridge Still Warm After Replacing a Bunch of Parts
- Mailbag: No Water from the Fridge Water Dispenser
- Mailbag: Stinky Ice!
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Adapting to Adaptive Defrost
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Loud or Weird Noises in Your Fridge
- Mailbag: Recharging an RV (propane-powered) Refrigerator
- Mailbag: Refrigerator Runs Constantly
- Mailbag: Refrigerator Door Gasket Replacement
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Zen and the Art of Refrigerator Door Gasket Replacement
- Appliance Tip of the Day: No Ice in Your Whirlpool or KitchenAid Side-by-Side Fridge with In-Door Ice
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Icemaker Water Filters
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Storing Flesh Meats Safely
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Buying a New Refrigerator
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Loud or Weird Noises in Your Fridge



