The Rational Art of Troubleshooting
by Samurai Appliance Repair ManThis email from one of my Live Help disciples is a great illustration of the kind of attention to detail and concentration you need to have while troubleshooting. I like to call troubleshooting the “rational art.” Yes, there are techniques and cause-and-effect relationships that you need to know but, as illustrated in this repair story, there’s also something more, something supra-rational that isn’t learned in text books; this is the Edge of the troubleshooting katana.
In this repair story, my apprentice, Chris, is struggling with a GE wall oven that kept throwing an F3 code while in use. Typical of most F-codes, the manual simply says to check the sensor and its connector. Chris did this and found nothing unusual. The sensor resistance at room temp was normal. We talked about it on the phone and I recommended that he get another sensor resistance reading at a higher temp to rule out the possibility of a non-linear response from the sensor. This is where the story picks up.
Samurai Appliance Repair Man
http://fixitnow.com
Sent from my iPhone
Begin forwarded message:
From: Chris H.
Date: September 13, 2007 6:18:20 PM EDT
To: Samurai Appliance Repair Man
Subject: success!Scott,
FYI I did test the oven sensor. It was perfect at boiling water. So I set it in a pan of cooking oil and used my turkey fryer thermometer, cranked the oil up to 500 degrees with the sensor in it, hooked to my multimeter.
Its supposed to do ~2 ohms for every degree F above room temp. So at 212 in water it drew almost exactly 1380 OHMS, could even watch it go up with the heat. Same with the oil at 400 degress it was supposed to draw 1756 ohms and at first it was perfect at about 1790 OHMS. I was bummed at first and gave up but after a few more minutes, actually as I turned it off it jumped to 2400 ohms around 440 degrees! This is incorrect, it should be 1836ohms at 440. As it cooled, the ohms stayed in the 2400 range until around 300, then jumped back down to 1550 or so. Interesting. Not sure what went wrong in the sensor to be so erratic. Its 11 years old and get heavy use.
A new sensor has been placed and all is functioning well. The new one did come with ceramic wire nuts BTW.
another samurai success story.
CH
General Appliance Wisdom FAQs
- Appliance Repair Tool of the Day: VersaPak Cordless Screwdriver
- The Ten Commandments for Working With Household Power
- Samurai Certification for Electronic Circuit Board Analysis
- Requiem for Xdrive
- 30-Day No-Hassle Return Policy on Appliance Parts
- New and Improved Three-Step Samurai Appliance Repair Program and Appliance Repair FAQ Pages
- Appliantology Newsletter, Fall 2008
- Protect your Electronified Appliances with Surge Suppressors
- Samurai Fixit Cam
- Getting Started in the Samurai Appliance Repair Forums: The Movie
- Maytag Appliance Use and Care Manuals
- Use the Forum, Luke!
- Using GFCI Outlets with Appliances
- How to Find Appliance Parts Without Having to Know Much
- The Famous Three-Step Samurai Appliance Repair Program
- Working with Electronic Circuit Boards in Appliance Repair
- General Appliance FAQ
- Mafia Goon Learns Appliance Repair from the Samurai
- Tips for Painting Appliances
- Spiffy New Parts Search Engine from RepairClinic
- Troubleshooting and Repairing Major Appliances
- United Samurai Beer Fund
- Leave a Message for the Samurai
- "Who are you and what's your problem, dude?"
- Appliantology Newsletter, Fall 2007
- Cool Tools for Fixit Fools
- Archives
- Fixitnow.com Sitemap
- How to Get Help in the World-Famous Samurai Appliance Repair Forum
- Appliance War Story: Urban Appliance Repair
- Appliantology Newsletter, Summer 2007
- Samurai Appliance Repair Apprenticeships
- Appliance Deconstruction Techniques Illustrated
- Adventures of a New Appliance Technician
- Love Means Never Having to Say Goodbye... to Your Appliances
- Thermador and Other High-End Brands are Less Reliable than Mid-Range Appliances
- Meet the Appliantology Masters
- Where Have All the Tradesmen Gone?
- Staber Washer Fan Mail
- Mega-trends in Appliance Repair
- Magic Serial Number Decoder for GE Appliances
- Broken Information Appliance
- Appliantology Newsletter, Winter 2006
- It's Cold Outside and the Furnace in My House Just Died!
- The Samurai's Rock 'n Roll Appliance Repair Mystery Tour
- Mailbag: Using a Digital Multimeter in Appliance Repair
- Tales from the Buttcrack, Episode No. 1,897: Defective Customers
- Meet Cheeky the Appliance Repairclown...
- Use the Form, Luke!
- Using a GFI (Ground Fault Interrupter) with Appliances
- The Samurai Appliance Repair Forum Ch-ch-ch-changes
- RepairClinic Earns the Coveted Intergalactic Samurai-Approved Certification
- Pamper your Appliances!
- Appliantology Newsletter, Fall 2006
- Appliance Brand Recommendations
- Miele Appliance Technical Training
- Repair Inspiration at Fixitnow.com
- Appliance Design Magazine, July Edition
- Does Your Appliance Servicer Have the Skills Needed to Repair Your Appliances?
- Appliance Repair Radio: How to Use the Samurai Appliance Repair Forum
- Appliantology Newsletter, Summer 2006 Issue is Now Out!
- Appliance Repair Radio: How to Use Fixitnow.com to, well, Fix It Now
- Basic Appliance Troubleshooting Flowchart
- Samurai's Appliance Repair Photo Galleries
- Appliance Repair Radio: Appliance Service Calls
- Appliance Repair Radio: How Much is a New One?
- Bureaucrats "Approve" Whirlpool and Maytag Merger
- Appliantology Newsletter, March 2006
- Announcing Fixitnow.com Appliance Repair Radio
- Nanny-State Alert: New Hampshire Contemplates Licensing Requirements for Gas Fitters
- Maytag Shareholders OK Sale to Whirlpool
- Appliance Repair: A Dying Trade
- Get Ready to Pay More for New Appliances
- Glorious Washer Repair
- Horizontal Axis Washers: Are They Worth the Money?
- Fixed a Washer With Dad
- Appliantology Newsletter, November 2005
- Fixitnow.com Message of the Day
- The Story of "O!" (that being our painful exclamation as we get screwed again and again by Big Gubmint and Big Corporations)
- How to Make Electrical Measurements; how to use a volt-ohm meter; how to measure electricity
- Using Archived Pearls of Wisdom from the Samurai Appliance Repair Forum to Fix Your Insolent Appliances
- The Naked Truth about being an Appliance Repair Tech
- Using the Concept of Appliance Half-Life to Determine When to Replace an Old Dryer (or any other appliance)
- Subscribe to Appliantology: The Oracle of Appliance Enlightenment
- Who Made my Kenmore?
- Background Information on LG, Siemens, and Samsung Appliances for Consumers; appliance reviews
- Appliantology Newsletter for July-August-September 2005
- Samurai's 12 Laws of Appliance Repair
- Are Maintenance Agreements Worth the Money?
- Laundry Room Horrors: Shout it Out!
- Appliantology Newsletter for May/June 2005
- Shakin' and Bakin' at the Samurai School
- The Way of the Samurai
- GE: Bringing Anything-but-Good Appliances to Life
- Appliantology Newsletter for April 2005
- What's All the Fuss About Power Quality?
- Appliantology Newsletter for March 2005
- Appliance Repair Mania
- Coughin' Up More Cash for New Appliances
- Fixite Do: The Ancient Martial Art of Appliance Repair
- Appliantology Newsletter for February 2005
- "Is There a Washer and Dryer Worth Buying?"
- Let the Samurai Help you Fix It Yourself!
- Spiffy New Appliance Parts Lookup Tools
- Appliantology Newsletter for January 2005
- Appliantology 3000 Microchip Implant Now Available!
- Samurai Appliance Repair Apprenticeship Training
- Whirlpool Taking Over Fisher & Paykel?
- Appliance Repair Revelation, The Secrets of Household Electricity... REVEALED!
- Mailbag: Making Simple Repairs Complicated
- Appliantology Newsletter for December 2004
- Master Appliantologists at the Appliantology Group Repair Forum
- Appliance Repair Revelation, Making Basic Electrical Measurements
- Mailbag: Mental Therapy for Appliance Repair
- Appliantology Newsletter for November 2004
- Mailbag: Washer and Dryer Recommendations
- Appliantology Newsletter for October 2004
- The Samurai's Martial Art of Appliance Repair
- Appliance Wisdom from On High
- Why Whirlpool Is Cleaning Up
- 15-Second Appliance Tips Airing on WNTK
- New Trouble for Ol' Lonely
- Service Call from Hell
- Bounce This Around
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Electrical Requirements for Household Major Appliances
- Get Pearls from the Samurai
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Appliance Power Usage
- New Economy Appliance Repair Service Coming Soon to Your Town!
- Appliance Tip of the Day: How Hard Will It be to Fix It?
- Samurai to Go!
- Appliance Satori
- Poll: Do-It-Yourself Appliance Repair
- Appliance Jive Turkey Award: A Sears/A&E Servicer in South Florida
- Mailbag: How to Get Help With Your Appliance Problem
- Appliance Tip of the Day: How Hard Will It be to Fix It?
- Mailbag: Hot Water Heater Gets Cold too Fast
- Appliance Tip of the Day: How Long Should Appliances Last?
- Mailbag: Changing Parts Without a Clue
- Appliance Tip of the Day: How Hard Will It be to Fix It?
- Appliance Service Calls...Samurai Style
- Fix It Yourself and Save Big Bucks!
- Mailbag: GE Appliances
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Rodent Rage
- Appliantology: "How Much is a New One?"
- Mailbag: Are Extended Warranties on Appliances a Rip-off?
- Appliantology Goes to Press
- Mailbag: Appliance Brand Recommendations
- Appliance Repair Tool of the Day: Non-Contact Voltage Light Stick
- On Sale Now!
- Septic Salvation
- Call for Service
- Mailbag: Making Gas Connections...Safely
- Whirlpool Appliance Technical Help Online
- Samurai on the Job: Every Appliance Repair Man's Nightmare
- New Repair Photos at the Appliantology Group
- Mailbag: Discharging and Testing a Capacitor
- Mailbag: Appliance Service Ripoff Update
- Mailbag: Preventing Mold and Mildew in Basement Carpet
- Mailbag: Appliance Service Ripoff?
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Appliance Power Usage
- Appliance Tip Of the Day: Phixit Photos
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Indoor Air Pollution Control
- Appliance Tip of the Day: The Ten Commandments for Reading Appliance Model Numbers
- Libertarian Appliance Repair
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Energy-Saving Appliances
- Share the Love, Yo!
- Cheesedork Alert!
- Appliance Tip of the Day: "How Much is a New One?"
- Appliance Tip of the Day: The Hard Facts About Hard Water
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Use and Care Manuals
- Appliance Service Calls
- Appliance Tip of the Day Encore: Genuine Appliance Manufacturer's Repair Manuals
- Appliance Usage Handbook
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Troubleshooting and Repairing Major Appliances
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Money Saving Tips for Commercial Kitchens
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Who REALLY Made Your Appliance?
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Genuine Appliance Manufacturer's Repair Manuals
- Appliance News Update
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Storing Flesh Meats Safely
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Use and Care Manuals
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Your Detergents Suck
- Appliance Recall Alert
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Appliance Service Calls
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Ohm's Law
- Frequently Asked Questions
- The Samurai's Rules of Etiquette
Oven Repair FAQs
- GE Recalls Wall Ovens Due to Fire and Burn Hazards
- Whirlpool / KitchenAid Microwave Combination Built-In Ovens with Error Code "door"
- How to Remove the Control Panel on a Frigidaire Wall Oven
- Cooling Fan in a Jenn Air Range Runs On and On and ...
- Wolf Appliance Recalls Gas Ranges Due to Burn Hazard
- Replacing the Thermostat in a Gas Range with Standing Pilot Ignition
- How to Replace the Ignitor in a Gas Oven: A Pictorial Guide
- Gas Oven Taking Longer to Pre-Heat
- Oven Temperature Sensors
- Getting the Door Back on a Thermador Range
- GE Recalls Tens of Thousands of Combination Microwave / Conventional Wall Ovens
- Oven Repair FAQ
- Oven/Range Troubleshooting and Repair Manual
- Electrical Outlets for Electric Ovens, Ranges, and Stoves
- How to Troubleshoot an Electric Oven that Doesn't Heat Up
- GE Wall Oven with F7 Error
- How to Open the Control Panel on a Jenn Air or Maytag Slide-In Range
- How Does the Gas Valve work in a Gas Oven?
- Gas Stove Burners Sparking Like They're Possessed
- How to Re-Calibrate the KitchenAid Dual-Fuel Ranges
- How Much Money Will You Save by Doing Your Own Appliance Repairs?
- Whirlpool Direct Spark Ignition Range Won't Stay Lit or Re-Ignite
- How to Unlock the Door of an Older GE Range
- How to Fix a DCS Range That Won't Fire Up After Self Clean
- Complete Listing of All Error Codes for All Thermador Cooking Products
- Wolf Oven Goes BANG!
- GE Profile Oven with an Intermittent F7 Error Code
- Jenn Air SVE47600B Cooling Fan Comes on Early and Often
- Home on the Range
- "My Oven Temperature is Out of Whack"
- Tres Oven Tips Just in the Nick o' Time for Cooking Season
- Fahrenheit or Celsius Temperature Selection in GE Ovens
- How to *Know* if Your Gas Oven Ignitor is Bad (without guessing)
- Removing the Door Gasket on a Dacor Range
- Jenn Air Electric Range Beeps Incessantly; No Fault Code
- Kitchenaid Built-in Oven Blowing Thermal Fuse
- Frigidaire 30" Free-Standing Ranges with Mini-Oven: Beeping Sound from Control Panel but No Fault Code
- Can't get the door back on a Whirlpool wall oven
- Replacing a bake element in a GE oven... maybe
- Dim LCD display on Jenn-Air wall oven clock
- Maytag, Amana, Jenn Air, and Magic Chef Range F1 Codes
- Understanding the Temperature Control Circuitry in a Jenn Air Range
- Massive Recall Of GE Professional Gas Ranges...
- KENMORE DOOR LOCK ERROR
- Gas oven goes boom when starts
- Gas Oven Goes Boom When It Starts; gas oven ignition problems, gas oven repair
- Amana Gas Oven Won't Fire Up; Oven Ignitor Wires; Oven Repair
- Thermador Electric Wall Oven Won't Bake; oven repair
- Gas Stove Goes Boom When It's Turned Off; stove repair, range repair, oven repair
- Kenmore Oven Door Lock Problem
- KitchenAid oven disaster
- Maytag Range F1 Error Code
- Oven Thermostat Repair Lab Report
- How to Know that a Range ERC is Bad
- Mailbag: Using Your Gas Range to Heat Your Home
- Mailbag: Bad Ignitor or Valve on a Gas Oven?
- Appliance Repair Revelation, Converting a Gas Range
- Mailbag: E1 - F5 Fault Code on a Kenmore Range
- Maytag Recalls Jenn-Air Gas Ranges
- Mailbag: DCS Range Parts
- Mailbag: Oven Pilot Flame Goes Out
- Mailbag: GE Profile Oven with Error Codes
- Fire in the Hole!
- Mailbag: Converting an Electric Range Outlet
- Mailbag: Gas Stove Burners Won't Ignite Automatically
- Mailbag: Toaster Repair
- Mailbag: Oven Electronic Control Board is Broken and No Longer Available
- Mailbag: Gas Range Repair Guesswork
- Inspiration from the Master: Range LED Display is Dim
- Mailbag: Range Error Codes
- Mailbag: "Repairing" a New Oven Thermostat
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Getting Ready for Cooking Season
- Mailbag: F7 Error Code on a GE Built-In Oven
- Mailbag: Twin Toaster Tribulations
- Mailbag: Gas Oven Won't Fire Up (Redux)
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Gas Oven Ignition Systems
- Mailbag: Gas Oven Won't Fire Up
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Oven Temperature Sensors Demystified
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Range Clock Fault Codes
- Appliance Tip of the Day: Sooty Burner in Your Gas Oven



